New Delhi: The Supreme Court, on
Thursday, sought to know whether the Board of Control for Cricket in
India (BCCI) secretary N. Srinivasan would consider giving up one of the
two hats he was wearing — that of BCCI secretary and IPL franchise
owner — till the Madras High Court disposed of a suit filed by former
BCCI president A.C. Muthiah alleging conflict of interest in holding on
to both.
A two-judge bench, comprising Justices
J.M. Panchal and Gyansudha Mishra, suggested this as an interim
arrangement during the course of hearing of an appeal filed by Muthiah
against an interim order of the Madras High Court declining to prevent
Srinivasan from contesting for the post of president in the September 29
elections.
Srinivasan’s counsel Mukul Rohatgi said
there was no conflict of interest in being both BCCI secretary and India
Cements-owning Chennai Super Kings.
However, Justice Gyansudha Mishra demurred
saying that the basic issue in this case was about eligibility and
conflict of interest. She also pointedly asked the counsel to ask his
client to choose whether he would be a member of the BCCI or would
continue to be an owner of Chennai Super Kings.
“You can’t wear two hats. Till the main
suit is decided you apply this option.” She asked Rohatgi to seek
instructions from his client on this.
“You tell him to resign as member of BCCI
and continue to own the IPL side or be a member of BCCI and relinquish
the ownership of IPL,” she said. “You choose either of these,” she
added. “You can’t continue in two capacities.”
She wondered what prejudice would be caused to Muthiah if this option was exercised in the interim.
Rohatgi at this juncture clarified that
Srinivasan was not the owner of Chennai Super Kings. “The owner is India
Cements. I am one of the 12 directors of India Cements.”
The counsel said that though Srinivasan was the managing director, he was not the “owner”.
But Justice Mishra insisted that since the
allegation was about him influencing the “decision-making” process, he
should consider exercising this option.
Rohatgi, however, argued that the whole
suit against Srinivasan was actuated by mala fide. “Grave prejudice will
be caused if I am prevented from contesting to the post of BCCI
president,” he argued on behalf of Srinivasan.
“That choice cannot be put to me as I am not the owner. India Cements is the owner,” he claimed.
Rejecting Muthiah’s argument that the
corporate veil has to be pierced to unveil the truth about Chennai Super
Kings’s ownership, Rohatgi said that the corporate veil can only be
lifted (by courts) as an exception in cases of fraud and some other such
reason. “It cannot based on bald and vague allegations.”
Justice Mishra then sought to know how
such a major decision as changing a rule was taken by the working
committee (which had 10 members) as opposed to the Board (which has 30
members).
“Is it not conflict of interest? You are
the secretary. Can’t it be said that you influenced the decision of the
working committee? “
After all, the main allegation was that
the amendment was carried out without following due procedure. As per
procedure all members have to have notice of the intent to change the
rule before it was carried out.
However, Muthiah’s counsel Abhishek Manu
Singhvi in his counter-argument insisted that the suit was maintainable.
The BCCI rules specified that there should be no conflict of interest
either direct or indirect, he contended.
That rule was changed to exempt IPL,
Champions League and Twenty20 from its purview. Muthiah initially
complained to the BCCI but after his complaint was ignored went to the
Madras High Court. Arguments will continue on September 21.
|
We provides Daily latest news from India and the world. Get current top stories, business, sports and Bollywood headlines with photo galleries and much more.
Showing posts with label Sports News. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sports News. Show all posts
Friday, September 17, 2010
Choose between BCCI and IPL...
Champions League Twenty20, 2010 - Mumbai Indians vs Guyana, Kingsmead, Durban, Match 10
Champions League Twenty20, 2010 - Mumbai Indians vs Guyana, Kingsmead, Durban, Match 10
Match Result: Mumbai Indians beat Guyana by 31 runsMan of the match: Kieron Pollard Series Status:
Toss won by: Mumbai Indians Status : Match Ended Batted First : Mumbai IndiansBatted Second : Guyana
| Total: 184 for 4 in 20.0 overs Run Rate: 9.2 | |
Mumbai Indians Innings
|
| Batsman | Status | Runs | Balls | 4's | 6's |
| Shikhar Dhawan |
c Esuan Crandon b Devendra Bishoo
|
39
| 37 | 3 | 1 |
| Sachin Tendulkar (C) |
st Derwin Christian b Devendra Bishoo
|
48
| 39 | 6 | 0 |
| Kieron Pollard |
not out
|
72
| 30 | 1 | 9 |
| Saurabh Tiwary |
c Christopher Barnwell b Devendra Bishoo
|
0
| 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Ambati Rayudu (W) |
b Esuan Crandon
|
4
| 5 | 0 | 0 |
| JP Duminy |
not out
|
14
| 6 | 2 | 0 |
| Dwayne Bravo | |||||
| Harbhajan Singh | |||||
| Zaheer Khan | |||||
| Lasith Malinga | |||||
| Ali Murtaza | |||||
| Extras : 7 (b - 0, w - 5, nb - 0, lb - 2, Penalty - 0) | ||||||
| Fall of wickets:1/82 (Sachin Tendulkar 10.5 ov.), 2/98 (Shikhar Dhawan 14.2 ov.), 3/99 (Saurabh Tiwary 15 ov.), 4/152 (Ambati Rayudu 18.3 ov.) | ||||||
| Bowlers | Overs | Maidens | Runs | Wickets | Wides | Noballs | Econ |
| 4 | 0 | 46 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 11.5 | |
| 4 | 0 | 44 | 1 | 3 | 0 | 11 | |
| 4 | 0 | 33 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 8.25 | |
| 4 | 0 | 25 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 6.25 | |
| 4 | 0 | 34 | 3 | 1 | 0 | 8.5 | |
| Total: 153 for 6 in 20.0 overs Run Rate: 7.65 Target: 185 |
Guyana Innings
|
| Batsman | Status | Runs | Balls | 4's | 6's |
| Travis Dowlin |
c Saurabh Tiwary b Dwayne Bravo
|
7
| 18 | 0 | 0 |
| Sewnarine Chattergoon |
c JP Duminy b Lasith Malinga
|
1
| 6 | 0 | 0 |
| Ramnaresh Sarwan (C) |
c Lasith Malinga b Harbhajan Singh
|
46
| 38 | 6 | 1 |
| Narsingh Deonarine |
c Shikhar Dhawan b Dwayne Bravo
|
27
| 23 | 3 | 0 |
| Christopher Barnwell |
c Sachin Tendulkar b Harbhajan Singh
|
24
| 15 | 3 | 1 |
| Royston Crandon |
not out
|
16
| 14 | 1 | 1 |
| Jonathan Foo |
c Ambati Rayudu b Zaheer Khan
|
1
| 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Esuan Crandon |
not out
|
2
| 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Derwin Christian (W) | |||||
| Devendra Bishoo | |||||
| Paul Wintz | |||||
| Extras : 29 (b - 8, w - 17, nb - 0, lb - 4, Penalty - 0) | ||||||
| Fall of wickets:1/15 (Sewnarine Chattergoon 2 ov.), 2/45 (Travis Dowlin 7 ov.), 3/91 (Narsingh Deonarine 12.5 ov.), 4/118 (Ramnaresh Sarwan 15.3 ov.), 5/137 (Christopher Barnwell 17.3 ov.), 6/148 (Jonathan Foo 19 ov.) | ||||||
| Bowlers | Overs | Maidens | Runs | Wickets | Wides | Noballs | Econ |
| 4 | 1 | 17 | 1 | 3 | 0 | 4.25 | |
| 4 | 0 | 28 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 7 | |
| 3 | 0 | 18 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 6 | |
| 4 | 0 | 33 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 8.25 | |
| 2 | 0 | 22 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 11 | |
| 3 | 0 | 23 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 7.67 |
CL T20: Mumbai crush Guyana by 31 runs
Durban:
Kieron Pollard's 30-ball 72 massacre, including 9 sixes and one four,
helped Mumbai register their opening points in the Champions League
after beating a hapless Guyana by 31 runs on Thursday at Kingsmead.
Mumbai
innings - which was helped by some shoddy ground fielding and catching
by the Guyanese side - looked scratchy to begin with after Sachin won
the toss and elected to bat despite overcast conditions. But once the
opening partnership crossed fifty, Sachin & Co. eyed a score close
to what they eventually ended with.

However, an opening stand of 82 runs between the Mumbai skipper and Shikhar Dhawan followed Sachin's (48) dismissal against the run of play, when spinner Devendra Bishoo got him stumped to claim his first wicket.
Sachin's
wicket led to another two in quick succession, both to Bishoo. The
tweaker first had Dhawan (39) caught at mid-wicket, followed by Saurabh
Tiwary who failed to disturb the scorers.
From 82 for
no loss, Mumbai Indians slipped to 99/3 at the end of 15 overs. Kieron
Pollard – who was promoted to No. 3 to counter an eventuality of rain
interruption – remained a spectator until then, watching wickets fall
around him. However, that didn't prevent the West Indian butcher to
clobber a hapless Guyanese team in what turned out to be the innings of
the tournament.
What
followed was an uninhibited display of aerial hitting that sent Guyana
on a leather hunt and shattered Ramnaresh Sarwan's dream of restricting
Mumbai to under 150.
A staggering
85 runs came off the last 30 balls of Mumbai innings, taking them to an
unprecedented 184 runs at the end of 20 overs.
Bishoo remained the most impressive bowler for Guyana with his three wickets for 34 runs in four overs.
An
under-pressure Guyana outfit needed an inspirational innings from their
skipper Ramnaresh Sarwan. But before him, the openers needed to fire,
which sadly didn't happen as S Chatergoon (1) failed once again, giving
Malinga and Mumbai the first wicket.
Travis
Dowlin (7) too never looked in and after a scratchy partnership of 30
runs with Sarwan, fell prey to fellow West Indian Dwayne Bravo.
From that
moment on, it was always Sarwan vs Mumbai. And the Guyana skipper did
give Mumbai a little scare for a while with some support from Narsing
Deonarine.
But that
didn't last long as Deonarine (27) fell to a fabulous forward-diving
catch by Shikhar Dhawan, ending a 46-run stand and giving Bravo his
second victim of the match.
Sarwan
continued to be the only hope, if there was any, for Guyana. And his
wicket proved to be the final nail hammered in by Harbhajan Singh, when
Sarwan ended up hitting straight into Malinga's hands in quest for quick
runs.
With a few easy wickets on offer in the end, Zaheer picked up one whereas Harbhajan and Bravo ended with a brace each.
But Kieron
Pollard's innings turned out to be difference between the two teams in
search of their first win in the tournament. The hurricane he brought
onto the field left Guyana clueless and they failed to come out of it,
going down tamely in the end.
Thursday, September 16, 2010
Latif targets getting Test status for Afghanistan in two years time
Former Pakistan Test captain Rashid Latif, who is all set to join Afghanistan cricket team as its head coach
following his resignation as the wicket-keeping coach of the National
Cricket Academy, has said that his goal is to get Test status for
Afghanistan in the next two years.
"My job is to train the Afghan team and prepare a back-up line for them for future," the Daily Times quoted Latif, as saying.
He pointed out that without a proper back up, any team who was getting Test status could not survive long.
Latif
also said he had sorted his minor differences with the Afghanistan
Cricket Association. "I have accepted the offer after sorting out
differences with them."
He confirmed that he would be joining the
Afghan team in Dubai on September 17 where they are preparing for Inter
Continental Cup.
The 41-year-old coach will be taking over the
new responsibility from compatriot Kabir Khan, who resigned over
differences with the Afghan cricket authority after last month's
Scotland tour.
Latif played 37 Tests and 166 one-day
internationals (ODIs) in an illustrious career that also saw him
campaign against corruption in the game. He had been wicket-keeping
coach at the NCA since late 2008. (ANI)
Spain still the best, according to Fifa rankings
![]() |
| World Cup winners Spain have won the opening two matches of their European Championship qualifying campaign |
Winners of the World Cup Spain stay at the top of Fifa's latest world
rankings, with Germany and England rising after back-to-back wins in the
European Championship qualifiers. The rankings see France, who lost a home
Euro 2012 qualifier to Belarus, dropping six places to No 27 – their worst
position since the rankings were introduced in 1993.
Les Bleus were seventh at the start of the year
but their qualifying struggles follow a dismal World Cup performance
that was overshadowed by splits in the camp leading to the bitter
departure of their coach Raymond Domenech and leaving several leading
players facing lengthy bans from the squad.
Spain's
shock 4-1 defeat to Argentina meant their lead narrows over the
Netherlands, their World Cup final opponents. Germany are third, and
Brazil drop to No 4. The Argentines stay at No 5, with England now sixth
ahead of Uruguay, Portugal, African champion Egypt and Chile.
Fifa updated the standings, which weigh results
over a four-year cycle, using 159 international matches played over five
weeks. Euro 2012 and 2012 African Cup of Nations qualifiers carried the
most points.
Norway and Slovakia jump to No 14
and No 16 respectively – the Slovaks' best ever – on the back of two
wins apiece while Turkey rise seven places to No 21.
The United States remain at No 18 and World Cup quarter-finalists Ghana climb three positions to No 20.
Switzerland,
Australia and Russia drop out of the top 20. The Australians remain the
top Asian confederation nation at No 24. New Zealand lead the Oceania
nations at No 49. Montenegro rise to their best-ever ranking of 40th –
up 33 places after Euro 2012 wins against Wales and Bulgaria – despite
not being a recognised national team until three years ago.
The
Balkan country cut its football ties with Serbia after they played at
the 2006 World Cup and was admitted as Fifa's 208th and newest member in
May 2007 with a ranking of 199.
Euro 2012
results also saw Lithuania, Cyprus and Northern Ireland leap at least 10
places into the top 50. Belarus jump 23 places to their best of 55th on
the back of that famous defeat of France.
The
summer's World Cup hosts South Africa rise eight places to No 58 – their
best ranking in three years – after beating Ghana in a friendly and
Niger in an African Cup of Nations qualifier. The Cape Verde Islands
used a qualifying win over Mali to jump 31 places to No 77, and
Guinea-Bissau's victory over Kenya in its first match since December
2007 lifted it 48 places to No 140.
Qatar, who
are seeking to host the World Cup in 2022, drop six places to No 104
after a trio of drawn friendlies against Bosnia-Herzegovina, Bahrain and
Oman. The organisers of Qatar's bid are to showcase a specially
designed stadium this week which is supposed to keep fans and players
cool while protecting the environment.
The
stadium is part of organisers' efforts to convince Fifa inspectors, who
are visiting this week, that the country can hold the tournament despite
temperatures reaching 50C in the summer. The inspectors include six
delegates, led by the Chile Football Federation president Harold
Mayne-Nicholls.
Qatar is the final stop on a
tour of nine countries which are bidding to host the 2018 or 2022 World
Cups. Fifa will announce the winners in December.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
